1. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
In Columbus, Mikey’s Late Night Slice is pretty much what the name says: a spot for late-night cravings and bold pizza flavors. Whether you’re out with friends or wandering after a long shift, this place feels like home. People come here not just because it’s open long after other pizza spots shut their doors, but because the slices have this chewy-yet-crispy crust that hits different. You’ll get the answer to What is New York style crust? when you bite in — thin, foldable, and just a bit of char from the stone oven.
There’s nothing fancy about the ordering process. You get in, grab a hot slice (sometimes two), and choose from sauce drips that range from slappy heat to savory and creamy. The menu isn’t endless, but they’ve nailed the basics:
- Big cheese slices, perfect if you keep it classic.
- Spicy pepperoni, always a top seller, bringing grease, crunch, and salt in every bite.
- Creative specials, like the Taco Pizza or the pizza topped with creamy garlic drizzle.
For anyone curious about how business brokers operate, Mikey’s feels a bit like a community hub — you’ll overhear chats about everything from how business for sale brokers find the perfect buyer to stories about the wild world of automotive business brokers. Sometimes, there’s even talk about someone looking for an internet business for sale while waiting in line for their pizza!
| Favorite Slice | Crust Texture | Open Late? |
| Cheese | Thin, Crisp, Foldable | Yes |
| Pepperoni | Charred, Chewy | Yes |
| Specialties | Varies by recipe | Yes |
Mikey’s philosophy seems simple: provide good pizza, open late, don’t complicate things, and let folks have a spot to gather when the rest of the city is winding down.
2. Harvest Pizzeria
Harvest Pizzeria keeps it simple: good food, made with ingredients you can pronounce, and crust with a bit of chew. Their focus on local produce means you can actually taste the difference in every slice. Whenever I think about a place for pizza night with friends, Harvest always tops my list—cozy vibe, friendly staff, and pies that don’t mess around with weird toppings.
A few reasons why regulars keep coming back:
- Unique pizza recipes, including a killer Spicy Yuma and a fan-favorite Ohio Double Bacon
- Freshly made dough every single day
- Locally sourced vegetables, meats, and cheeses
If you’re someone who asks business brokers or business for sale brokers about local spots worth buying into, Harvest Pizzeria always pops up. Even folks looking into the internet business for sale market sometimes wish they could replicate Harvest’s loyal following.
| Pizza Type | Notable Ingredient | Price Range |
| Spicy Yuma | Jalapeños, corn, chipotle cream | $13-$15 |
| Ohio Double Bacon | Smoked bacon, provolone | $14-$16 |
| Roasted Garlic | Roasted garlic, feta | $12-$14 |
Catching up with friends at Harvest is never a letdown—the pizza’s always hot, the playlists are laid-back, and you walk out wanting to come back next week.
Bottom line: If you’re hunting for something a little different from the usual carryout joint, this spot nails it without any drama. Automotive business brokers might have their own favorite pizza, but in a Columbus neighborhood on a Friday night, Harvest is hard to beat.
3. Dewey’s Pizza
Dewey’s Pizza has been a regular stop for Ohio pizza fans, and there’s a clear reason: their menu is straightforward, but every option feels like comfort food. The combination of a chewy, flavorful crust and fresh mozzarella sets Dewey’s pies apart from the rest. If you’re hunting for both classic and inventive pizzas, Dewey’s does not disappoint. I’ve seen groups of friends order up a giant pepperoni with a Greek salad on the side, but the real fun is in trying their specialty pies like the Edgar Allan Poe—a flavor bomb with spinach, olives, and roasted garlic.
Here’s a quick breakdown of some favorites:
| Pizza Name | Toppings Included | Recommended For |
| Edgar Allan Poe | Olive oil, mozzarella, goat cheese, | Adventurous eaters |
| mushrooms, olives, roasted garlic | ||
| Peppercorn Ranch | Chicken, bacon, tomatoes, ranch drizzle | Crowd-pleasers |
| Green Lantern | Mozzarella, goat cheese, artichokes, | Veggie lovers |
| garlic, pesto |
- Seating always feels open and casual, great for families or a casual business lunch.
- Service is consistent; orders rarely take long even during dinner rushes.
- If you’re a regular, they remember your slice (this actually happened to me once—felt like a TV moment).
Dewey’s has found a sweet spot with families and college students alike, making it likely you’ll run into someone you know there.
A funny twist: Dewey’s is a popular spot for business brokers and real estate agents to meet clients for lunch. Apparently, there’s something about the comfortable atmosphere (and maybe the famous calzones) that gets people talking, whether it’s about finding an automotive business brokers group or scoping out the latest internet business for sale listings. That laid-back vibe works, even for business for sale brokers just dropping by for a pie. If you haven’t given Dewey’s a try, go on an empty stomach and leave room for leftovers.
4. Bricco
Bricco lands on this list for a reason: their pizza stands out with its unique combo of bold toppings, perfectly charred crust, and creative flavor pairings. If you haven’t been to Akron, Bricco alone makes it worth the trip. They’re not only about pizza, either—the menu is stacked with options, so if someone in your group isn’t feeling a slice, they’ve got choices.
Here are a few things that set Bricco apart:
- Hand-tossed crust with a just-right balance of chewy and crisp
- Rotating specialty pizzas that highlight seasonal ingredients
- Friendly staff who actually know the menu and like chatting about their favorites
Oh, and if you’re the type that checks Google and Yelp before trying a new spot, Bricco usually racks up 4+ stars with plenty of regulars. Pizza fans working long shifts—like some business brokers or folks in automotive business brokers—like that it’s a good place for unwinding after work, too.
| Pizza Type | Price Range | Fan Favorite Topping |
| Classic Margherita | $12-15 | Fresh Basil |
| Meat Lovers | $14-17 | Italian Sausage |
| Veggie Supreme | $13-16 | Roasted Red Pepper |
You might head in thinking about a simple slice, but Bricco’s menu—especially for anyone curious about new flavors or even scouting for an internet business for sale over a lunch meeting—will turn your night into something memorable.
5. Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza
Adriatico’s is something you just have to try if you’re after real-deal New York style pizza in Ohio. Their slices are huge, thick with melty cheese, and come out piping hot every single time. This spot in Columbus is popular with students and locals, especially anyone craving that perfect, foldable slice that doesn’t skimp on toppings—or flavor.
Here’s what really stands out about Adriatico’s:
- Super generous portions. One slice could honestly fill you up.
- Their signature garlic crust is something folks talk about for days after.
- Laid-back, friendly atmosphere. You never feel rushed here.
| Pizza Style | Price (per large pizza) | Most Popular Topping |
| New York Style | $16 – $24 | Pepperoni |
You might not think about business brokers or business for sale brokers over a pizza, but it’s funny—Adriatico’s has become one of those places where people celebrate all kinds of wins. From talking automotive business brokers dreams, to laughs over internet business for sale ideas, this place feels like a local landmark.
The moment you walk in and catch that smell, it’s clear why Adriatico’s is at the top of pizza lists in Columbus. If you’re hungry, bring a friend—these slices are no joke.
6. Gionino’s Pizzeria
Gionino’s Pizzeria has been one of Ohio’s go-to spots for solid, craveable pizza since opening its doors back in the ’90s. It’s a local chain that’s grown by word of mouth—one mouthwatering slice at a time. There’s something about their buttery, slightly crispy crust that just hits the right note, especially if you’re after a classic style but want a bit more flavor than the usual delivery place. Gionino’s brings in locals with their signature garlic sauce, piled-high toppings, and dough that never seems frozen or bland.
People love to grab Gionino’s for any occasion: last-minute family gatherings, work lunches, or those random nights when you’re just not in the mood to cook. The menu isn’t just pizza, though—that’s a big part of the fun. You’ll find wings, loaded subs, chicken dinners, and fresh salads too. For folks comparing Gionino’s to somewhere like Dewey’s or Harvest Pizzeria, the prices lean friendlier, so it’s a solid value for what you get.
Here’s a quick look at what Gionino’s fans seem to order most:
- Gionino’s Best pizza (It’s sausage, pepperoni, veggies, and a whole lotta cheese)
- Jojo potato wedges paired with their chicken
- Classic Italian sub loaded with meats and melty provolone
| Specialty Item | Approx. Price (Large) | Notable Feature |
| Gionino’s Best | $21 | Loaded toppings, garlic crust |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza | $20 | Housemade BBQ sauce |
| Jojo Potatoes | $7 | Crispy, garlicky sides |
Don’t be surprised if you end up with leftovers—Gionino’s doesn’t hold back, and reheating is no problem the next day.
If you’re thinking of moving to a spot with prime pizza access or even browsing through business for sale brokers for your own slice shop, Gionino’s is the sort of neighborhood favorite that sets a high bar. It’s also a place locals talk up when chatting with business brokers or even automotive business brokers about what makes a great local food stop. That “always-fresh, never-fussy” vibe means you can count on having a good meal almost any time you walk in—Gionino’s gets pizza right, plain and simple, and if you’re looking for an internet business for sale in food, a model like theirs might be one to watch.
7. Mama Santa’s
In Cleveland’s Little Italy neighborhood, Mama Santa’s stands out thanks to its old-school charm, classic flavors, and bustling vibe. This spot has been keeping locals happy for decades, dishing out pies that are as comforting as they are memorable. Their dough is simple but tasty, and their sauce has a hint of sweetness that people keep coming back for.
What really makes Mama Santa’s pizza unique is the homemade touch. The toppings feel fresh—best sellers include sausage and mushroom, or the famous pepperoni. They’re not messing around with trends here. This is pizza the way you remember it growing up, with family recipes that haven’t changed much at all. Bring a friend or the whole family; the large pies are seriously big.
Mama Santa’s doesn’t just fill your stomach, it fills up with regulars every single weekend—locals swear by it. Be sure to plan for a wait if you go during dinner hours. Parking’s not great, but the walk is worth it. You might not discover internet business for sale tips here, but you will get a slice that’s earned every bit of its reputation—business brokers and locals alike rave about this spot.
- Classic pizza recipes handed down through generations
- Known for light, crisp crust and generous toppings
- Located in Cleveland’s historic Little Italy
- Offers pies perfect for groups and celebrations
It’s not rare to bump into business for sale brokers or even local automotive business brokers grabbing a slice at Mama Santa’s before heading back to work—everyone in the area knows it’s a Cleveland staple.
8. Tommy’s Pizza
Tommy’s Pizza has been serving the Columbus area since the 1950s, and honestly, walking into one of their shops feels like stepping back in time. Their crust is thin and crisp, the edges browned just the right amount, and the sauce has a nice tang. Cheese and toppings go all the way to the edge, which is always a win for me. If you’re stuck deciding, the pepperoni is a staple, but don’t skip out on their sausage either—classic flavors that keep regulars coming back for years.
A few things you’ll notice right away at Tommy’s:
- Plenty of locals going for lunch and dinner—always a good sign
- Fast and friendly service, hardly any wait for a table most days
- Generous portions on both whole pies and by the slice
Here’s a quick comparison of their popular pizza sizes and prices (as of October 2025):
| Size | Slices | Price (USD) |
| Small | 6 | $10 |
| Medium | 8 | $14 |
| Large | 12 | $18 |
Try Tommy’s if you’re after old-fashioned pizza that hasn’t changed much in decades—perfect for a weekday treat or low-key weekend plans.
You might spot flyers on their front desk for business brokers or see ads about business for sale brokers online while waiting. Funny thing—locals even joke that if you ever see Tommy’s listed by automotive business brokers or on some internet business for sale website, that’s when you know Columbus is changing for real! But for now, Tommy’s stays right where it’s always been: the same pizza, the same neighborhood, just how people want it.
9. Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza
Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza in Columbus is a spot you remember—not just for the late-night hours but for the way they let you build out your pie exactly how you want. This place draws all kinds: students, families, people on their way home from a night out. What sets Hounddog’s apart from the rest on the best pizza in Ohio list is their signature spicy sauce and thick, chewy crust.
Here are a few reasons Hounddog’s keeps people coming back:
- Three sauce options: traditional, garlic butter, and that wickedly spicy sauce
- Generous toppings—seriously, every bite is packed
- Known for their Three Degree pizza challenge (not for the faint of heart)
| Feature | Details |
| Location | Columbus, OH |
| Signature Sauce | Spicy ‘Three Degree’ Sauce |
| Hours | Open late, 7 days a week |
The vibe inside is casual, with groups clustered around tables and music playing in the background. This is the kind of place business brokers might meet up to talk deals over pizza, or someone interested in business for sale brokers might drop in for a think and a slice. Even automotive business brokers could probably use a break here and there, and to be honest, the buzz of people talking about everything from the internet business for sale listings to the latest big game gives the place energy.
Anyone in central Ohio looking for the best pizza in Ohio owes themselves a stop at Hounddog’s—it’s the kind of pizza joint where you find your favorite order and stick with it forever.
10. Pizza Cucinova
Pizza Cucinova is the kind of place where you end up with a pizza that tastes just the way you wanted, even if you didn’t know exactly what that was when you ordered. They let you choose exactly what goes on your pizza, and they’ll build it in front of you—no guessing games.
Here’s what stands out when you eat at Pizza Cucinova:
- Fresh dough is rolled out to order, so every base is chewy, crisp, and hot.
- You can mix and match toppings—try Italian sausage with roasted veggies or stick to basics like pepperoni and cheese.
- The staff moves quick, so even when it’s busy, you won’t be waiting forever.
If you care about the details, their pricing is straightforward. Here’s a quick look:
| Pizza Size | Base Price | Extra Toppings |
| Individual (10″) | $8.99 | $1.00 each |
| Large (14″) | $14.99 | $1.50 each |
Walk-ins, families, students, and business brokers all squeeze into the same space, and mostly everyone leaves grinning. Unlike what you’ll find at some internet business for sale spots or specialty shops, here it’s about good crust, good toppings, and no fuss. If you’ve ever wondered where automotive business brokers go for a bite during a work break, I’d bet a slice it’s here.
There’s something about watching someone load your pizza with fresh ingredients and then fire it in that big stone oven that makes the whole meal feel special, even if it’s just a quick lunch.
Wrapping Up the Pizza Hunt
So, after all this talk about pizza, I’m honestly getting hungry. Ohio has a lot going on when it comes to pizza, and there’s something for everyone. Whether you like thin crust, deep dish, or something in between, you’ll find a spot that hits the spot. Some places are old-school, others are new and trying out wild toppings, but they all have their own thing going on. Next time you’re in the mood for a slice, maybe try one of these places. Who knows? You might find your new favorite. And if you think I missed a great spot, let me know—there’s always room for more pizza adventures.
